Payson, AZ

Metro area in Arizona · Updated Jan 2026

12-Month Forecast ↑ +0.9%

Median Home Value

$376,718

↓ -1.8%

Year-over-year

Median Rent

$1,778/mo

Year-over-year

Rental Yield

5.7%

Good for investors

5-Year Appreciation

+35.3%

Active Listings

385

For-sale inventory

Price-to-Rent Ratio

17.7

Neutral market

Price Forecast

1 Month

↑ +0.1%

3 Months

↑ +0.3%

12 Months

↑ +0.9%

5-Year Price Trend

Calculate your mortgage for Payson, AZ

See monthly payments for a $376,718 home →

Should you rent or buy in Payson, AZ?

Price-to-rent ratio: 17.7x — It depends on your timeline. Run a full breakeven analysis with Payson, AZ numbers pre-filled →

Frequently Asked Questions